Does Crowd Intelligence Always Win?

BY HEROX ADMIN | 1 min read

The concept of ‘idea markets’ has been gaining fame ever since James Surowiecki wrote his book on crowd wisdom back in 2005. If you want answers, don’t just go to just one person—go to many people! But is crowd intelligence always the best choice?

The Study

A recent study in Seoul aimed to put this to the test. Researchers took 500 people and gave each 8 tasks. The tasks ranged from easy (what is the high temperature in Seoul today?) to hard (if all poor people in the world gave you $1 each, how much sustainable monthly income could you derive from the resulting amount?). How did people do on their own versus in a crowd?

The Result

When it came to the easy tasks, both the crowd and those on their own performed the same, but that was to be expected. The weather outside is pretty much a black and white matter. It was the harder tasks that raised a few eyebrows - people did better on their own. When faced with tasks they couldn't answer, people in a crowd just started guessing. Researchers couldn’t make heads or tails out of the results. There was no consensus, just a bunch of random answers. Collective intelligence failed. 

It was the mid-range tasks that saw a hugh jump in crowd performance over those who worked on their own. The tasks needed info from a wide range of sources, so access to a group of people proved to be the best asset. Those on their own could only rely on their own knowledge, and often came up short. 

The Insight

The lesson from this research is that crowd intelligence can beat out a single mind, but only if the crowd can grasp the task at hand. Ensure your tasks are not too easy or too hard – ones just right – and the crowd will come through. Research proves it!

Original Article

more like this
HeroX + Crowdsourcing Week - The Future of Innovation
HeroX joined the Crowdsourcing Week team on their latest crowd session - Crowdsourcing and Prize Challenges: Shaping the future of Innovation. Learn more about the event and listen back to the live recording
0 min read
Data Science
Who was Robert J. McEliece and the people behind this Cryptosystem?
Learn more about the mathematicians behind one of the world's most secure annd valuable cryptosystems.
1 min read
Data Science
Scalability of New Approach Methodologies (NAMs) and their Global Impact
Check out these five potential impacts that NAMs could have on the scale of medical research across the whole world.
3 min read